Who Gets to Decide What’s Best for Our Parents?

I sat quietly while my husband and his brother discussed their aging parents.

How often should they visit? Who should be the first phone call if something happened? What if one of their parents had an accident while we were on vacation? What if they needed help and neither son could get there quickly enough?

The questions kept coming.

Both brothers lived in different states from each other and from their parents. Their dad was getting older, and their stepmother seemed to be declining faster than anyone had expected. My husband’s brother had recently visited and noticed changes since the last time he’d seen her.

We were scheduled to visit in a few weeks.

Would we notice the same things? Would she be worse? And if she was, what exactly were we supposed to do about it?

I recognized every question.

Years earlier, my sister and I had sat through our own versions of that conversation. Our parents were aging, illnesses were becoming part of everyday life, and the distance between where they lived and where we lived complicated everything.

We wanted to help. We wanted them safe. We wanted to anticipate problems before they became emergencies. Mostly, we wanted answers to questions nobody could answer.

I remembered arguing with my mother about moving closer to us. My sister and I lived in the same area. Our mother had moved several states away to care for her aging father, and after he passed, she wanted to stay.

We thought she should move back. It made sense to us. We could visit more often, help when she needed something, and be close enough to respond if something went wrong.

She didn’t agree.

My mother was stubborn. She had strong opinions about how she wanted to live, and she wasn’t particularly interested in changing them simply because her daughters thought they had a better plan.

She also wasn’t always realistic about what she expected other people to provide. And that was where things became complicated.

She wanted to stay, but she needed financial help. Helping her maintain a life several states away wasn’t something we could realistically continue doing. Eventually, we made the decision that she needed to move.

She wasn’t happy about it.

I don’t regret that decision. Even now, I can’t think of another workable solution. We did what we could with the circumstances and resources we had.

But sitting there listening to my husband and his brother, I realized I understood something differently now. My mother had every right to want to stay where she was. I also had every right to decide what I could afford to give.

Those two things didn’t have to agree.

Perhaps that was what had been so difficult all those years ago. We weren’t just dealing with aging parents. We were trying to sort out whose decisions belonged to whom.

When we’re raising children, making decisions for them is part of the responsibility. We assess risks, establish boundaries, and sometimes say no because we can see consequences they can’t.

Then our parents begin aging, and something strange happens. That same instinct takes over. We see what could go wrong. We recognize the risks. We come up with solutions that seem perfectly reasonable.

We expect them to listen.

Except these aren’t children.

These are people who have spent their entire adult lives making their own decisions. They have preferences, routines, habits, and opinions. Some of those opinions have probably been driving us crazy for decades.

Getting older doesn’t necessarily make them any more agreeable. My mother certainly didn’t become a different person simply because she needed help. She was who she was. And I didn’t have to agree with every choice she made to recognize that.

So as my husband and his brother continued discussing all the possibilities, I offered one suggestion.

Why not ask their parents what they wanted?

It sounded simple enough.

But I knew it wasn’t.

There's something incredibly difficult about asking the people who once had all the answers what they want from us as their lives begin to change. Especially when you’re not sure you want to hear the answer.

What if they don’t want to move? What if they refuse help? What if they believe everything is fine when you’re beginning to wonder whether it is?

What if they want something you simply can’t provide?

A few weeks later, we made our visit. My husband had plenty of questions he could have asked his dad. There were things he wanted to understand, concerns he wanted to address, and possibilities he wanted to prepare for. He asked a few questions, not the thousand he’d arrived with. Then he did something I appreciated.

He simply spent time with them.

We cooked a few nice meals. We sat together in their favorite room of the house and listened to stories. We made jokes. We laughed. There were no grand solutions. No comprehensive plan for every possible emergency.

His parents were still aging. The concerns that had prompted the conversation with his brother hadn’t disappeared. But for those few days, we weren’t trying to solve everything that might happen. We were enjoying what was happening.

I found myself wondering how many visits I’d spent with my own parents worrying about what came next. How many conversations had been about medications, appointments, living arrangements, finances, or things that needed to change?

All necessary conversations, certainly. But not every conversation needed to be one.

When we landed, two of my children met us at the airport. We were catching up on everything that had happened while we were gone when my husband asked my daughter a question.

“How are you feeling about everything going on in your life?”

“Fine,” she answered.

One word.

He immediately looked at me.

That’s my answer when I have neither a complaint nor any particular excitement about a situation. Just fine. Nothing more needs to be said. He laughed and pointed out that after a lifetime of listening to me, apparently that was one of the things she’d chosen to carry forward.

A few minutes later, my son offered another familiar phrase.

“I just need your undying love and affection.”

One of my favorite sarcastic responses. My husband shook his head.

Apparently, my children had inherited more of my personality than I’d realized. On the drive home, my husband and I were still laughing about it when he asked me a question.

“What do I do that’s just like my dad?”

I thought for a moment.

“You put peanut butter on your waffles. So does your dad.”

Silence. Then a slow nod.

Of all the things he’d inherited from his father, there was one sitting right there on his breakfast plate, something he'd never thought to question.

I kept thinking about that conversation.

Our children grow up watching us. They adopt our expressions, our habits, our peculiar ways of doing things. Some of those things they carry into adulthood without even realizing where they came from. Some of their observations result in the complete opposite of what we did.

We carry things from our parents too. We spend years becoming independent of them, making our own choices, building our own lives. Then one day we find ourselves sitting around a table discussing how best to manage theirs.

When exactly did that happen?

More importantly, did anyone ask them if they wanted us to?

I know there may come a time when difficult decisions have to be made. I’ve lived through those years. I know that wishes and circumstances don’t always fit neatly together, and sometimes the help someone needs comes with limitations nobody particularly likes.

I also know that worrying about every possible future doesn’t make us any more prepared to live through it.

My husband’s parents are still making their own decisions. They’re safe. They have their routines, their preferences, and their own ideas about how they want to spend their days.

We might do things differently. That doesn’t automatically make our way better.

We can offer help. We can ask questions. We can be honest about what we’re able to provide. And when the circumstances require more, we’ll deal with what is actually in front of us. Until then, maybe we don’t need to turn every visit into a discussion about what happens next. Maybe we can cook dinner, listen to another story we’ve probably heard before, and laugh at the same old jokes.

After all, my husband has spent his entire life eating peanut butter on his waffles.

His dad is still his dad.

And he’s still his son.

Jesse Sloane Studio

Jesse Sloane Studio is an independent literary studio exploring the unexamined beliefs that shape our lives.

Through books, essays, and creative work, the studio examines the stories we inherit about love, loss, identity, ambition, and what a meaningful life is supposed to look like.

Every project begins with a simple question: What if the story you’ve been living isn’t the only one available?

https://www.jessesloanestudio.com
Previous
Previous

Apparently, Pride Doesn't Know How to Run a Theater

Next
Next

Apparently, I've Been Handling Pumpkins Wrong for 56 Years